“A rather light story of romance well clothed in detailed settings and atmosphere are the points most noticeable in this latest Pathé release. As the plot unfolds, at the beginning, there is a slight confusion of ideas due to the switching from modern day locale to the ancient and vice versa, and, owing to this confused state of affairs the grip upon the attention of the audience is lessened. But after the passing of the second reel the suspense and interest becomes more pronounced making the final three reels very entertaining. A number of strong dramatic situations and a couple of thrills add materially to the worth of the story. The theme deals with the reincarnation of spirits—that love never dies but lives on and on from one generation to the other—with the resulting improbabilities that usually bloom from stories of this description. The scenery of Florida is responsible for some beautiful locations that appear in the film. The cast is exceptionally pleasing in their respective parts and do much to increase the value of the story. While this picture might not be as good as previous Thanhouser releases, still there is no doubt but that it contains enough entertaining qualities to satisfy the average audience. Its freedom from melo tendencies makes it desirable for community theatres.”
REVIEW by Agnes Smith, The Morning Telegraph, January 14, 1917:
“The Image Maker is a fanciful drama of reincarnation. Its heroine is a moving picture actress who is in love with a rich young man. The villain is a moving picture magnate who behaves exactly as a Pennsylvania censor believes a film producer should act. Aided by the hero’s father he parts the couple. The girl goes to Egypt with her company to act for the camera. Interwoven with this plot is the romance of a prince of ancient Egypt and a beautiful Circassian girl, image maker for the tombs. When the pharaoh, father of the prince, learns of the affair, he orders the girl thrown to the crocodiles. The two stories are brought together when the moving picture actress and the man she loves, the reincarnation of the Egyptian lovers, are reconciled at the tomb of the prince. The stories are enacted in beautiful and appropriate surroundings. There are some very convincing bits of Egypt shown; they are so good, in fact, that one wishes the producer had not given away the secret by laying the early scenes of the story in Florida. The sacrifice of the Circassian girl, who is thrown in a river teeming with crocodiles, is ultra-realistic. The reptiles tear her limb from limb and then crawl out on the muddy banks of the stream, licking their chops and looking considerably plumper. Valkyrien is well cast in a fantastic and semi-poetical role and the supporting cast is good.”
REVIEW by Laurence Reid, Motion Picture Mail, January 27, 1917:
“Valkyrien seems to have a penchant to appear in fantastic pictures, and this entertainment recalls to us Hidden Valley, in which she was seen earlier in the year. There is a similarity of plot construction and of character development about the two stories. In this tale, The Image Maker, Valkyrien presents a striking picture of a reincarnated Egyptian maid, and if she is the re-embodied spirit of the image maker, no wonder the Prince of Tsa went quite mad about her and forfeited his life in the bargain. It is a story of ancient and modern love. In the ancient tale Valkyrien is shown as a beautiful image maker in love with an Egyptian prince. Unfortunately, the Pharaoh doesn’t approve of the romance, for she is thrown to the crocodiles, and the prince meets with a fatal injury. In the modern story, Valkyrien appears as a moving picture actress. It happens that the right man comes along and an attachment springs up between them.
“Apparently they are Egyptologists, and when reading a book, Romances of Ancient Egypt, consider themselves the reincarnated lovers of their favorite chapter. Occurrences happen that separate the sweethearts for a time, but they are later reunited in Egypt at the prince’s tomb. The stories are woven together in an admirable manner, and the handling of the appropriate settings reflects studied carefulness on the part of the director. The Egyptian atmosphere was delightfully conveyed by means of Florida settings. There were the fat, sleek crocodiles that devoured the image maker. Incidentally, they furnished a comedy stroke in their antics. There was the Nile and the palm trees and the tombs and the ruins of the Pharaohs. The acting was up to requirements, and the photography was admirable. The Image Maker is a pleasing offering.”