1913Thanhouser CompanyOne reelDrama

What Might Have Been

No copy you can watch online. No print is known to survive. What follows is what does: the release, the cast, the story, and what the trade press said at the time.

The story

“The old broker was very wealthy, but he was very old and very homely. In his younger days he had been too mean and stingy to marry, and as the years passed he could not see any reason for giving up his liberty. Finally the time came when he fell in love with his stenographer. She was young and pretty, but they did not have one taste in common and had they married their life would undoubtedly have been decidedly unhappy. Just the same, the broker proposed and was mighty surprised when the girl rejected him. She did not tell him who his favorite rival was, but he speedily learned that the lucky man was one of his own clerks, a handsome chap drawing an extremely small salary. The broker at first planned all sorts of things, such as discharging the young couple or intimidating them in some manner, and was still brooding over revenge that evening when he fell asleep at his own handsome fireplace. Naturally he dreamed of what he would like to do, and in his dreams he cleverly rid himself of his rival by proving him guilty of burglary; then there was no bar to his marriage with the girl, especially after (in his dreams) the young convict had been shot down while trying to escape from prison.

“If the dream had stopped there, perhaps the old broker would have tried something of that kind, for he was a man absolutely without conscience. Maybe a good angel took a hand in the development of the dream. The broker imagined that after he had proposed to the girl, the spirit of the dead convict came between them, haunted him in a most unpleasant way, and finally choked him so vigorously that he was glad to wake up. Now although the broker was old and inclined to be foolish in some matters, he had lots of sense otherwise. He took the dream as a warning of what might have been, and quickly decided that no woman in the world was worth such torments as he had just gone through, so he called the young couple into his office, raised the bridegroom’s pay, and bade them marry and be happy forever afterwards.”

Summary from The Moving Picture World · 6 December 1913

What the papers said

1 review · 1 advertisement

“A dream story, in which Riley Chamberlin appears as a broker in love with his stenographer. The dream illustrates the things that might have happened to his young rival. This is an entertaining reel, but not very strong in plot or presentation.”

The Moving Picture World · 13 December 1913

Advertisement

29 November 1913Reel Life1 min

“A wealthy broker is smitten with his pretty stenographer, only to lose her to a petty clerk in his own employ—who had ‘looks.’ The broker plans the couple’s immediate discharge and all manners of revenge, the folly of which is summed up to him in a wondrous and enlightening dream.”

Have you seen this film, or a print of it?

Prints of films thought lost still turn up in attics, private collections and archives. A record like this one is how the next one gets found.

Tell us about a print

Cast and crew

Cast
Arthur Bauer as policeman
William Noel as policeman
Ethyle Cooke as Marie, his stenographer
George Barnes as police lieutenant
Harry Benham as Billy, his clerk
Nick S. Woods as Rolfe’s butler
Riley Chamberlin as Rolfe, the old broker

Every name opens that person's page, with each film they appear in and which of them you can watch.

Watch instead

Films you can watch from the same company

Matched by cast, director and kind

More about this film

From Volume II: Filmography of Q. David Bowers’ Thanhouser Films: An Encyclopedia and History, reproduced with permission and unchanged. Read the history of 1913 →

Cite as: Bowers, Q. David. Thanhouser Films: An Encyclopedia and History, “What Might Have Been”. thanhouser.org/films/what-might-have-been/

Where a print is held

Held by
No print known