“As a whole: full of action; story: gripping; star: gives finished performance; support: excellent; settings: in keeping; photography: clear.
“Under False Colors is an interesting story written about the Russian Revolution, but for the most part the scenes are laid in America. Frederick Warde, the able tragedian, is cast as an American capitalist, who is financing the revolution, and brings into play every bit of his strong personality and wonderful stage experience. In support appears Robert Vaughn as Jack Colton, his son; Jeanne Eagels as Countess Olga, and Carey Hastings as Mrs. Colton. The play is full of action and contains plenty of suspense. The direction of Emile Chautard is superb and the photography clear throughout. The story was written by Lloyd Lonergan and is a photoplay that should please the most exacting audiences.
“The story: Colton sends his son Jack to Russia to complete the details of a loan to that government. While there Jack assists the Countess Olga, who is hounded by spies, out of the country. She sails for America and on the same steamer meets Vera Ladislaus, who is going to make her home with the Coltons. The steamer is torpedoed and Vera loses her life. Olga, upon arrival in New York, poses as Vera, to secure information in the Colton home, as she has been told he was aiding the Russian government. Becoming established in the home, the kindness of the Coltons makes her regret her position. Jack’s return home, and the arrival of Vera’s father, an old friend of the Coltons, complicates matters. However, upon Colton’s statement to the assembled Russians at their headquarters that he is in reality helping the cause of freedom, Olga’s true feelings toward the Coltons, and especially toward Jack, are seen.”
REVIEW by Charles E. Wagner, Exhibitor’s Trade Review, September 22, 1917:
“A scene of timely interest and a story brimming over with human interest marks this production as an acceptable Pathé offering. While it does fail to place Frederick Warde in a character that is best suited to him, his characterization can at least be classed as pleasing. To find him in the role of an easy-going Wall Street broker might be disappointing to those who are used to associate Mr. Warde with more substantial roles, but nevertheless, those who are not familiar with Mr. Warde’s stage career will become reconciled to the production as it exists. The story deals with the present Russian revolution, eliminating any war stuff, but merely offering the intrigues of the Russian reactionaries in America. This point makes the production acceptable. There are a number of strong situations that are somewhat novel for the usual modern day photoplay output. One point in the plot development that hinders the sympathetic appeal surrounding the character of Olga is the haze surrounding the villainies of the leader of the Russians in America. Not until the very last will the audience discover that he is in fact really a villain. However, this point does not hinder the suspense or interest that the production contained. The direction is good and the photoplay entirely up to Pathé standard. The acting, too, is acceptable. Frederick Warde is appealing as the Wall Street broker, and while handicapped by limitations, still lends a touch of human appeal that is strikingly real. Jeanne Eagels does exceptionally well as the Countess Olga. She has never been seen in a role where her pleasing personality was so pronounced. The rest of the cast likewise should receive worthy commendations. Under False Colors will please the patrons of community or family theatres particularly. The theme is timely and the story itself is one that will supply an hour of clean entertainment. Furthermore, it is linked with the name of a star of unquestionable box office value.
“Balance of the program: A lively slapstick two-reel comedy together with a newsreel or split reel educational and cartoon comedy would be most appropriate. Musical suggestion: See cue sheet furnished by Pathé.”